Model Effect or Label Effect? Refined Annotations and a Human-Referenced Benchmark for Pulmonary Embolism Segmentation

2026-08-25

AI Summary

研究通过改进标注和建立人类参考框架，量化了评估标注对肺栓塞分割性能的影响，并使用nnU-Net模型比较了标注效果和模型训练效果。

Abstract

Purpose: To quantify how evaluation annotations influence measured pulmonary embolism (PE) segmentation performance relative to model training changes, and to establish a human-referenced framework. Materials and Methods: This retrospective study screened 166 voxel-annotated CT pulmonary angiography cases from CADPE (n=91), FUMPE (n=35), and READ (n=40); 149 were included. A primary rater annotated PE by protocol, and a senior thoracic radiologist reviewed and revised all segmentations. Three additional raters at three centers annotated a 15-case subset. The label effect was measured by evaluating two pretrained nnU-Net models (nnU-Net-A, nnU-Net-B) against original and refined annotations. The model effect was measured by comparing the same architecture trained on different dataset combinations with annotations fixed. The benchmark model (nnPE) was trained with leave-one-dataset-out and pooled five-fold cross-validation. Four metric categories were analyzed with case-paired Wilcoxon signed-rank tests, Benjamini-Hochberg correction, and bootstrap 95% CIs. Results: Changing only the annotation increased mean DSC by 0.143 (0.122-0.166) for nnU-Net-A and 0.188 (0.163-0.213) for nnU-Net-B (both P < .001), whereas changing training-dataset composition changed DSC by 0.028. The label effect exceeded the model effect on CADPE and FUMPE and was 0.045 on READ. Within-mask attenuation SD fell in all three datasets after re-annotation (all P < .001). nnPE reached DSC 0.72 +/- 0.22 on pooled cross-validation but scored below all four annotators across 52 paired comparisons (all corrected P < .05). Conclusion: Evaluation annotations affected measured PE segmentation performance at least as much as model training choices. A human-referenced evaluation framework is publicly available for future study.

Problem

• Pulmonary Embolism
• Segmentation
• Annotation
• Model Training
• Benchmark

Innovation

• refined annotations
• human-referenced benchmark
• pulmonary embolism segmentation
• label effect