Open Problems in Frontier AI Risk Management

📅 2026-04-28
📈 Citations: 0
Influential: 0
📄 PDF

career value

223K/year
🤖 AI Summary
This study addresses the growing challenges posed by frontier artificial intelligence, which not only amplifies existing risks but also introduces novel threats. Current safety practices struggle to respond effectively due to a lack of scientific consensus, misalignment with traditional risk management frameworks, and insufficient implementation. Adopting a problem-oriented approach, this work conducts a structured literature review and maps findings onto established risk management systems, complemented by multi-stakeholder analysis. It presents the first systematic categorization of open challenges into these three interrelated dimensions and establishes a dynamic online knowledge repository. The outputs include an agenda-setting reference document and accompanying resources that delineate a clear pathway for coordinated efforts in research, standardization, and regulation, thereby preventing redundant investments.
📝 Abstract
Frontier AI both amplifies existing risks and introduces qualitatively novel challenges. Not only is there a notable lack of stable scientific consensus resulting from the rapid pace of technological change, but emerging frontier AI safety practices are often misaligned with, or may undermine, established risk management frameworks. To address these challenges, we systematically surface open problems in frontier AI risk management. Adopting a problem-oriented approach, we examine each stage of the risk management process - risk planning, identification, analysis, evaluation, and mitigation - through a structured review of the literature, identifying unresolved challenges and the actors best positioned to address them. Recognising that different types of open problems call for different responses, we classify open problems according to whether they reflect (a) a lack of scientific or technical consensus, (b) misalignment with, or challenges to, established risk management frameworks, or (c) shortcomings in implementation despite apparent consensus and alignment. By mapping these open problems and identifying the actors best positioned to address them - including developers, deployers, regulators, standards bodies, researchers, and third-party evaluators - this work aims to clarify where progress is needed to enable robust and meaningful consensus on frontier AI risk management.The paper does not propose specific solutions; instead, it provides a problem-oriented, agenda-setting reference document, complemented by a living online repository, intended to support coordination, reduce duplication, and guide future research and governance efforts.
Problem

Research questions and friction points this paper is trying to address.

Frontier AI
risk management
scientific consensus
AI safety
governance
Innovation

Methods, ideas, or system contributions that make the work stand out.

frontier AI
risk management
open problems
problem-oriented approach
governance coordination
Marta Ziosi
Marta Ziosi
Oxford University
Artificial IntelligenceEthicsBias
M
Miro Plueckebaum
Oxford Martin AI Governance Initiative, University of Oxford
Stephen Casper
Stephen Casper
PhD student, MIT
AI safetyAI responsibilityred-teamingrobustnessauditing
H
Henry Papadatos
SaferAI
Z
Ze Shen Chin
Oxford Martin AI Governance Initiative, University of Oxford; AI Standards Lab
P
Peter Slattery
MIT Future Tech
J
James Gealy
SaferAI
Tim G. J. Rudner
Tim G. J. Rudner
Assistant Professor of Statistical Sciences, University of Toronto
Machine LearningUncertainty QuantificationInterpretabilityAI SafetyAI Governance
B
Brian Tse
Concordia AI
A
Ariel Gil
Pivotal Research
Patricia Paskov
Patricia Paskov
RAND
AI evaluationAI governanceeconomicsinternational development
M
Maximilian Negele
Oxford Martin AI Governance Initiative, University of Oxford
Rokas Gipiškis
Rokas Gipiškis
Vilnius University, Institute of Data Science and Digital Technologies
Machine LearningXAIInterpretabilityAI SafetyRisk Management
N
Nada Madkour
UC Berkeley Center for Long-Term Cybersecurity
V
Vera Lummis
Stanford University
Rupal Jain
Rupal Jain
Lifelong Kindergarten, MIT Media Lab
Educationcreative learningteacher professional developmentequity-centered
L
Luise Eder
Oxford Martin AI Governance Initiative, University of Oxford
K
Kristina Fort
Independent
M
Malou C. van Draanen Glismann
Stanford University
I
Inès Belhadj
Independent
A
Amin Oueslati
The Future Society
A
Anna K. Wisakanto
Center for AI Risk Management & Alignment
R
Richard Mallah
Center for AI Risk Management & Alignment
K
Koen Holtman
AI Standards Lab
R
Ranj Zuhdi
Independent