Asymptotically Fair and Truthful Allocation of Public Goods

📅 2024-04-24
🏛️ arXiv.org
📈 Citations: 0
Influential: 0
📄 PDF
🤖 AI Summary
This paper addresses the fair and strategyproof allocation of divisible public goods (e.g., municipal budget projects) among a large number of agents. Existing approaches suffer from error growth with agent count, limiting practicality. We propose PPGA—a differentially private randomized algorithm that integrates Nash welfare maximization with probabilistic approximation analysis. Theoretically, PPGA achieves asymptotic core stability (ensuring group rationality) and asymptotic truthfulness (discouraging strategic misreporting), both with high probability. Experiments on real-world participatory budgeting data demonstrate its efficiency and practical viability. To our knowledge, this is the first polynomial-time algorithm guaranteeing both asymptotic coreness and asymptotic truthfulness, establishing a new paradigm for large-scale public good allocation that bridges strong theoretical guarantees with real-world deployability.

Technology Category

Application Category

📝 Abstract
We study the fair and truthful allocation of m divisible public items among n agents, each with distinct preferences for the items. To aggregate agents' preferences fairly, we follow the literature on the fair allocation of public goods and aim to find a core solution. For divisible items, a core solution always exists and can be calculated efficiently by maximizing the Nash welfare objective. However, such a solution is easily manipulated; agents might have incentives to misreport their preferences. To mitigate this, the current state-of-the-art finds an approximate core solution with high probability while ensuring approximate truthfulness. However, this approach has two main limitations. First, due to several approximations, the approximation error in the core could grow with n, resulting in a non-asymptotic core solution. This limitation is particularly significant as public-good allocation mechanisms are frequently applied in scenarios involving a large number of agents, such as the allocation of public tax funds for municipal projects. Second, implementing the current approach for practical applications proves to be a highly nontrivial task. To address these limitations, we introduce PPGA, a (differentially) Private Public-Good Allocation algorithm, and show that it attains asymptotic truthfulness and finds an asymptotic core solution with high probability. Additionally, to demonstrate the practical applicability of our algorithm, we implement PPGA and empirically study its properties using municipal participatory budgeting data.
Problem

Research questions and friction points this paper is trying to address.

Fair and truthful allocation of divisible public items among agents with distinct preferences
Existing approaches suffer from non-asymptotic core solutions and implementation challenges
Proposing PPGA algorithm to achieve asymptotic truthfulness and core solution with practical applicability
Innovation

Methods, ideas, or system contributions that make the work stand out.

Uses Nash welfare maximization for core solution
Introduces PPGA for asymptotic truthfulness
Implements PPGA with participatory budgeting data
🔎 Similar Papers
P
Pouya Kananian
University of Waterloo, Canada
S
Seyed Majid Zahedi
University of Waterloo, Canada