From Bracha to Coded MBRB: Benchmarking Byzantine Reliable Broadcast Implementations

2026-09-07

AI Summary

该论文通过实现和评估三种拜占庭可靠广播算法，揭示了在不同负载下的性能瓶颈和操作权衡，使用了Go代码库、多种测试环境和故障注入等方法。

Abstract

Byzantine Reliable Broadcast (BRB) and Message-Adversary-Tolerant Byzantine Reliable Broadcast (MBRB) are reliable-dissemination abstractions for fault-tolerant distributed systems. Yet their operational behavior is shaped not only by specifications and asymptotic communication bounds, but also by serialization, cryptography, buffering, orchestration, deployment environment, and fault-injection semantics. This paper implements and evaluates Bracha [Information and Computation, 1987], AFRT by Albouy et al. [TCS, 2023], and Coded MBRB by Albouy et al. [OPODIS, 2024]. We implement the algorithms in a shared Go codebase with common orchestration, instrumentation, parser-based specification checks, fault injection, and an open-source reproducibility artifact. The evaluation uses single-shot broadcasts in the Shadow network simulator, native profiling, a Google Cloud Platform deployment, and a distributed FABRIC testbed, covering controlled experiments up to 30 nodes, payloads up to 40 MB, 92,190 runs, and 2,361,600 parser-checked entries. The results show that Coded MBRB reduces transmitted data and improves latency in the evaluated cloud setting for larger payloads, but shifts cost to cryptographic and coding computation. Bracha and AFRT incur lower CPU costs at smaller payloads, but their full-payload dissemination increases processing, allocation, and network costs as payloads grow. Across the tested configurations, the parser found no duplicate deliveries, conflicting deliveries, or deliveries of values different from the sender's payload. The paper contributes implementation-level evidence and an extensible artifact for benchmarking BRB and MBRB as executable distributed-system components, exposing bottlenecks and operational trade-offs that are hidden by algorithmic descriptions alone.

Problem

• Byzantine Reliable Broadcast
• Message-Adversary-Tolerant Byzantine Reliable Broadcast
• performance evaluation
• distributed systems
• fault tolerance

Innovation

• Coded MBRB
• reliable dissemination
• fault-tolerant distributed systems
• implementation benchmarking