How Wrong Can a Rank-Based Sample-Size Calculation Be? A Sharp Bound of 16/9 for Ordinal Outcomes

📅 2026-09-06
📈 Citations: 0
Influential: 0
📄 PDF
🤖 AI Summary
本文探讨了基于秩的样本量计算可能产生的误差,通过证明得出最大误差为77.8%,并提出该界限应作为设计敏感性证书使用。
📝 Abstract
Rank-based tests need no distributional assumptions to be valid, but the sample size they require does depend on the shapes of the two outcome distributions, which are unknown at the design stage. Standard practice substitutes a variance calibrated under the null. We ask how wrong that substitution can be. Writing $\Pi$ for the ratio of the true asymptotic variance of the estimated relative effect to the substituted one, we prove that under balanced allocation $\Pi \le 16\theta(1-\theta)/\{2+\theta(1-\theta)\} \le 16/9$ for all ordinal distributions in any number of categories: within the first-order asymptotic calculation the required sample size can exceed the calculated one by at most $77.8\%$, and an explicit two-point family attains the bound at every effect size. The effect-specific envelope, not the constant, is the operative quantity for a design: the ceiling falls to $1.63$ at $\theta=0.65$ and $1.37$ at $\theta=0.75$, so a trial powered for a larger effect is correspondingly less exposed. The proof is elementary. In five extracted trial comparisons and 4,711 generated alternatives the realized cost stays within a few percent, because the extremal configuration is one that shift-type treatment mechanisms do not produce. These facts are complementary, and fix how the bound should be used: it is a design sensitivity certificate, not an inflation factor. A protocol can report the conventional sample size alongside the largest requirement consistent with any ordinal configuration.
Problem

Research questions and friction points this paper is trying to address.

Rank-based tests
sample size calculation
asymptotic variance
ordinal outcomes
distributional assumptions
Innovation

Methods, ideas, or system contributions that make the work stand out.

rank-based tests
sample size calculation
ordinal outcomes
asymptotic variance
design sensitivity
💼 Related Jobs
No related jobs found.
A
Akarin Phaibulpanich
Department of Statistics, Faculty of Commerce and Accountancy, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand