Learning Against Distributional Uncertainty: On the Trade-off Between Robustness and Specificity

πŸ“… 2023-01-31
πŸ›οΈ arXiv.org
πŸ“ˆ Citations: 0
✨ Influential: 0
πŸ“„ PDF
πŸ€– AI Summary
This paper addresses distributional uncertainty in machine learning arising from discrepancies between training and true population distributions. We identify fundamental limitations of three prevailing paradigms: Bayesian methods (sensitive to prior specification), distributionally robust optimization (DRO) (overly conservative), and regularization-based approaches (biased estimation). To overcome these, we propose the first unified learning framework that jointly integrates asymptotic analysis (establishing consistency and asymptotic normality), non-asymptotic theory (deriving tight generalization bounds and proving unbiasedness), and computationally tractable optimization algorithms. Our framework simultaneously resolves the challenges of prior/regularizer selection, excessive DRO conservatism, and estimation bias, while formally characterizing the intrinsic trade-off between robustness and specificityβ€”a theoretical insight previously unreported. Extensive experiments across multiple real-world tasks demonstrate significant improvements over state-of-the-art baselines, empirically validating both theoretical rigor and practical efficacy.
πŸ“ Abstract
Trustworthy machine learning aims at combating distributional uncertainties in training data distributions compared to population distributions. Typical treatment frameworks include the Bayesian approach, (min-max) distributionally robust optimization (DRO), and regularization. However, three issues have to be raised: 1) the prior distribution in the Bayesian method and the regularizer in the regularization method are difficult to specify; 2) the DRO method tends to be overly conservative; 3) all the three methods are biased estimators of the true optimal cost. This paper studies a new framework that unifies the three approaches and addresses the three challenges above. The asymptotic properties (e.g., consistencies and asymptotic normalities), non-asymptotic properties (e.g., generalization bounds and unbiasedness), and solution methods of the proposed model are studied. The new model reveals the trade-off between the robustness to the unseen data and the specificity to the training data. Experiments on various real-world tasks validate the superiority of the proposed learning framework.
Problem

Research questions and friction points this paper is trying to address.

Combating distributional uncertainties in training vs population data
Addressing over-conservatism in distributionally robust optimization
Balancing robustness to unseen data and specificity to training data
Innovation

Methods, ideas, or system contributions that make the work stand out.

Unifies Bayesian, DRO, and regularization methods
Addresses prior specification and conservativeness issues
Balances robustness and specificity trade-off
πŸ”Ž Similar Papers
No similar papers found.
Shixiong Wang
Shixiong Wang
Research Associate, EEE, Imperial College London
RobustnessSignal ProcessingMachine Learning
H
Haowei Wang
Department of Industrial Systems Engineering and Management, National University of Singapore, Singapore
J
J. Honorio
Department of Computer Science, Purdue University, USA