In Pursuit of Privacy: The Value-Centered Privacy Assistant

πŸ“… 2023-08-10
πŸ“ˆ Citations: 0
✨ Influential: 0
πŸ“„ PDF
πŸ€– AI Summary
Users frequently overlook how personal values influence privacy decisions, leading to inconsistencies between app-download behaviors and stated privacy preferences. Method: This paper introduces Value-centered Privacy Assistant (VcPA), the first interactive prototype operationalizing value-centered privacy theory. VcPA constructs value-clustered user profiles, and implements three intervention mechanisms: selective notifications, alternative app recommendations, and exploratory prompts. A controlled study with 77 participants was conducted on a synthetic Mock App Store platform, integrating surveys, semi-structured interviews, and K-means clustering for behavioral modeling. Contribution/Results: VcPA significantly increased the rate of value-consistent app selections. Qualitative and quantitative analyses further identified critical usability bottlenecks and actionable design improvements. The work provides both theoretical grounding and practical implementation guidelines for deploying privacy assistance tools in real-world app stores.
πŸ“ Abstract
Many users make quick decisions that affect their data privacy without due consideration of their values. One such decision is whether to download a smartphone app to their device. Previous work has suggested a relationship between values, privacy preferences, and app choices, and proposed a value-centered approach to privacy that conceptually unites these relationships. In this work, we translate this theory into practice by constructing a prototype smartphone value-centered privacy assistant (VcPA) - a privacy assistant system that promotes user privacy decisions based on personal values. To do this, we designed and conducted an online survey that captured values and privacy preferences when considering whether to download an app from 273 smartphone users. Using this data, we constructed VcPA user profiles by clustering survey data based on the value rankings and stated privacy preferences. We then tested the VcPA, using selective notices, a"suggest alternatives"feature, and exploratory notices, with 77 users in a synthetic Mock App Store (MAS) setting and conducted follow-up semi-structured interviews. We establish proof-of-concept that a VcPA helps users make more value-centered app choices and identified improvements so that an assistant can be deployed on smartphone app stores.
Problem

Research questions and friction points this paper is trying to address.

Users make quick privacy decisions without considering personal values
Need for a system promoting privacy choices based on values
Developing a value-centered privacy assistant for app selection
Innovation

Methods, ideas, or system contributions that make the work stand out.

Prototype smartphone value-centered privacy assistant
Online survey clustering for user profiles
Mock App Store testing with selective notices
πŸ”Ž Similar Papers
No similar papers found.
S
Sarah E. Carter
D-REAL, Discipline of Philosophy, Data Science Institute, University of Galway, Ireland
Mathieu d'Aquin
Mathieu d'Aquin
Professor of Computer Science, UniversitΓ© de Lorraine, LORIA, IDMC
knowledge systemsontologiessemantic weblinked datadata science
D
Dayana Spagnuelo
TNO, The Netherlands
Ilaria Tiddi
Ilaria Tiddi
Assistant Professor, Computer Science Department, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
Knowledge RepresentationKnowledge ManagementHybrid IntelligenceMachine Learning
K
K. Cormican
Enterprise Research Center, School of Engineering, University of Galway, Ireland
H
Heike Felzmann
Discipline of Philosophy, University of Galway, Ireland