Tiny Moves: Game-based Hypothesis Refinement
This work addresses a key limitation in traditional machine learning approaches, which often model scientific hypotheses as monolithic end-to-end predictions and thereby overlook their inherently incremental and structured reasoning process. To bridge this gap, the authors propose the “Hypothesis Game” framework, which formalizes hypothesis refinement as a turn-based game mechanism for the first time. Within this framework, multiple large language model agents collaboratively perform localized, incremental revisions on a shared hypothesis state, guided by a symbolic grammar of reasoning actions. Emphasizing small, context-sensitive modifications rather than global rewrites, the approach significantly outperforms strong prompting baselines on error-correction tasks—achieving higher accuracy while better preserving the original hypothesis structure—and matches their performance on partial-clue reconstruction tasks, demonstrating both competitive efficacy and enhanced interpretability.