The Benefits of Diversity: Combining Comparisons and Ratings for Efficient Scoring
This work addresses the challenge of effectively integrating two distinct types of preference signals—individual ratings and pairwise comparisons—to improve the accuracy of inferred entity scores. The authors propose SCoRa, a unified probabilistic graphical model that jointly learns entity scores through maximum a posteriori (MAP) estimation. They provide the first systematic theoretical demonstration that combining both signal types yields significantly better performance than methods relying on either signal alone, particularly in accurately ranking top-tier entities. Theoretical analysis establishes the model’s monotonicity and robustness, while empirical results confirm that SCoRa reliably recovers true scores even under model misspecification and consistently outperforms baseline approaches that use only ratings or only pairwise comparisons in real-world scenarios.