AI Narrative Breakdown. A Critical Assessment of Power and Promise
This study addresses how dominant AI narratives often obscure the underlying political dimensions, power structures, and value-laden assumptions embedded in artificial intelligence, leading to misjudgments of its societal impacts and gaps in governance. Focusing on the discourse surrounding ChatGPT’s release, the project draws on an interdisciplinary synthesis of critical computer science, Science and Technology Studies (STS), data protection theory, semiotics, and philosophy of mind to systematically deconstruct the prevailing utopian/dystopian binary. It introduces the concept of “Zeitgeist AI” to uncover the implicit power relations and normative choices shaping AI development, emphasizing AI’s nature as a human-directed tool requiring robust social regulation. The work ultimately advocates for a more grounded, responsible AI discourse and governance framework attuned to these socio-technical complexities.